Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Stereotype and the Ethics of Representation




King

I read the third volume of King at the library. I really loved the gorgeous back and white ink drawings. It was a relief to see African Americans portrayed as actual humans instead of simians like the comics we’ve read before this.  Balancing hand painted drawings with actual photographs really reminded the reader that this was a historical piece. The monologues of different people giving their opinion about the king were also an interesting bit of story telling. What I really loved about this was the way that Martin Luther King Jr. wasn’t overly glorified. He was a great man but he wasn’t flawless. The comic also showed the King arguing with his wife. I thought his personal life was the most interesting part of the comic. It’s what we didn’t learn in our high school US History class. The moment when Coretta had to tell her daughter that she couldn’t go to the amusement park (because it was whites only) was heartbreaking. It was such a strong and real moment. This little girl didn’t even understand racism, because her parents protected her from it, it didn’t make sense to her. It’s because racism is outside of common sense.

Chicken with Plums

I’ve read Persepolis before and I was looking forward to this book, which wasn’t from her point of view. This book told the story of one of her relatives, Nasser. The wonderful thing about this story is the way that your opinion is constantly changing about Nasser as Marjane reveals more and more information about him through out his story. In the beginning we see Nasser is on his way to buy a new sitar to replace the one his wife broke. He thinks he sees a woman from his past but she doesn’t remember him. The new sitar isn’t good enough, so he decides to lie down and die. At first I was judging this strange man, I didn’t understand why he’d give up on life because his sitar broke. Later we realize that the sitar was the only thing that kept him going when he wasn’t allowed to marry the woman he loved. That lover was the woman that didn’t recognize him in the beginning. So in one day he loses sitar, which symbolized his love, and he sees that the woman he loved forgets him. It was such a well put and told story I had to read it twice.